Charlie Melancon: Tackles
tough tests in 1st term Post-hurricane record key to re-election bid Monday,
October 09, 2006 By Meghan Gordon The New Orleans Times-PicayuneNot
48 hours after he stood on the House floor to be sworn in to the 3rd Congressional
District office, Rep. Charlie Melancon got word from
half a world away of a tragedy that would reverberate in the swath of southeast
Louisiana he
now represented. A Democrat
from Napoleonville, Melancon had managed an exceedingly
narrow victory in a runoff against Billy Tauzin III, the heavily financed and
well-connected Republican son of the man who occupied the seat for 24 years. But
the luster of his win and his fancy new title seemed to dull immediately, Melancon
said, with news that six Louisiana National Guardsmen died Jan. 6, 2005. A roadside
bomb tore apart their Humvee north of Baghdad, marking the deadliest attack for a
single National Guard unit at that point in the 2-year-old war. "We were still on a high
from winning an election that people said we couldn't win," Melancon
said. "And when that happened, the reality of the war in Iraq and just the reality of the world
that's out there kind of sunk in real quick. "I came back down and started
thinking about what we needed to do and where we needed to go." The
casualties became just the first blow to the largely rural district during Melancon's
first year in Congress. Before he could gather 10 months of experience on Capitol
Hill, the 3rd District would be hit again, once on each end, by two of the country's
most damaging hurricanes. Now, as Melancon
campaigns for another term in Washington, his constituents have a voting record
with which to judge him and, perhaps more important, evidence of his response
to crippling disasters and his ability to pump resources into the district and
follow up on residents' individual requests for aid. Steering
the middle course Melancon,
59, still calls his birthplace of Napoleonville his hometown. He got a taste of
politics working for Edwin Edwards' 1971 campaign for governor and eventually
ran for and won a seat in the state House in 1987. After resigning from the Legislature
in 1993, Melancon took the helm at the American Sugar Cane League,
researching and lobbying on behalf of farmers and agriculture workers. In February
2004, he announced his bid for the seat that Rep. Billy Tauzin Jr., R-Chackbay, was vacating and eked out a close victory. He entered Congress as a member
of the minority Democratic Party and a Louisiana delegation that
had little seniority after heavyweights Tauzin and Democratic Sen. John Breaux
retired. Melancon joined the Blue Dog Democrats, a coalition
of fiscally conservative members of his party, and started voting on issues in
a style that he characterizes as centrist. "I kind of get caught in
between," Melancon said. "My party isn't always
happy with me because I don't vote with them down the line. And the other party
isn't happy with me because I don't vote with them down the line." That
other party includes state Sen. Craig Romero, R-New Iberia, who missed the 2004
runoff in the 3rd District by less than one percentage point and is back running
against Melancon this year. By the October congressional
recess this year, Melancon had voted with Democrats
80 percent of the time and with Republicans 62 percent on the more than 1,000
votes cast in the 109th Congress, including issues that received a consensus of
both parties. In rankings by special-interest
groups, Melancon's first-term voting record received
a mix of praise from conservative and liberal groups. He scored 50 percent with
the Gun Owners of America, 62 percent with the conservative Family Research Council
and 70 percent with the progressive National Committee for an Effective Congress.
He received more overt support from unions, such as the National Education Association,
the Service Employees International Union and the AFL-CIO, and derision from Planned
Parenthood and the Humane Society of the United
States. "His
style is more, 'Let's try to build a common ground and legislate from the middle,'
rather than, 'Let's push my viewpoint first,' " said state Rep. Reggie Dupre
of Montegut, a fellow Democrat who said he knows Melancon
well but endorsed state Rep. Damon Baldone, D-Houma,
in the 2004 congressional primary. "He tries to be as objective as possible."
Dupre
said it's much trickier to negotiate in Washington than in Baton
Rouge, where parties don't determine which bills are heard.
"You're forced, especially
as a freshman House member, no matter what party you're in, the party leadership
wants to try to tell you what you have to do," Dupre
said. "There's a fine line between keeping your independence and representing
your district, and having effectiveness." The
demographics of the 3rd District haven't made that tightrope walk any easier in
Melancon's first term. Though 60 percent of the district's
registered voters are Democrats, 58 percent of the district voted to re-elect
President Bush in 2004, and pollsters say a significant share carry conservative
ideals common in Southern districts that long ago switched to Republican majorities.
Keeping a low profile
As he did as a state representative
more than a decade earlier, Melancon the congressman set to work drafting bills for consideration.
None saw the light of day, a lesson Melancon said he
learned after a handful of attempts. "If
the majority party doesn't agree with what you want done or is not willing to
help you, you're not going to get your bill heard in a committee ever," he
said. "I introduced five or six pieces of legislation, but it came back to
me as, 'Don't plan on moving them.' " Melancon
said it simply taught him the value of building support behind the scenes. "You
can get more things done quietly rather than trying to be a press hog or trying
to get credit for stuff," he said. "That's the way I operate."
To that end, Melancon said he started forging
relationships with politicians on committees that held the fate of legislation
he considered important, such as expanding offshore oil and gas drilling, the
subject of a field hearing of the House Subcommittee on Energy and Mineral Resources
in Port Fourchon on Aug. 13, 2005. Sixteen days
later, Hurricane Katrina left St. Bernard and Plaquemines parishes, the eastern
end of the 3rd District, underwater. The storm would eventually give new urgency
to a campaign for using offshore oil royalties as a source of money to restore
the state's eroding coast. Diving into action Melancon
had evacuated to his daughter's Baton Rouge condominium
ahead of Katrina. He spent the better part of the first week after the storm visiting
deluged sections of the district to ask what local leaders most needed. "He
showed up right away and asked if there was anything we needed," said Plaquemines
Parish President Benny Rousselle, who backed Charmaine
Caccioppi during the 2004 congressional primary and
is supporting Melancon this time. Melancon
routed requests through the Federal Emergency Management Agency but quickly realized
he wasn't getting results. Tractor trailers loaded with food and water that his
office sent to the Crescent City Connection toll plaza to await airlift sat there
for days, Melancon said, because someone incorrectly reported the items
already delivered. So he concentrated on lining up those in need with direct
aid from donors, such as a California
philanthropist who chartered jets to ferry medical supplies into the region. Not
a month later, the west end of the district, untouched by Katrina, was slammed
by Hurricane Rita. Melancon's job for both storms
soon switched from attempting on-the-ground relief to mustering support on the
House floor for spending packages that the region needed in order to rebound.
Sitting in limbo With new fervor, the Louisiana
delegation latched on to an expansion of drilling beyond the continental shelf
as a major way to pay for long-term hurricane protection projects in southeast
Louisiana. Melancon
waited several weeks to sign on to the version pushed by Rep. Bobby Jindal,
R-Kenner. He said he was lining up support among Democrats, some of whom he feared
would dismiss it outright for environmental reasons. "The Democrats
are the reason we haven't had an energy bill . . . and that's my party,"
Melancon said. "So I've got to keep my party from
whipping against it, which if they whip against it, we wouldn't even have a House
version." The House eventually approved a bill that would lift a 25-year-old
drilling moratorium off the U.S.
coast and generate $9 billion in oil royalties for Louisiana in a decade. It scaled back the state's
share by about $1 billion over a previous version that would have given 75 percent
of oil and gas produced within 12 miles of shore to states, compared with the
successful bill's award of 25 percent of coastal states' royalties in the next
five years, increasing to 50 percent in a decade. "The bill that we
got in the House is very generous," Melancon said. "I knew from the beginning, when I first
read it, that we'd never get close to those kind of numbers
and things that we asked for. But there are some elements in there that are good
that can be put together, tied together with the Senate bill." Nevertheless,
the two chambers could not reach a compromise before the October recess, leaving
Melancon to return to campaign without what he surely
would have touted as a victory for southeast Louisiana had it passed.
Melancon said he is confident Congress will make progress
when it returns after the Nov. 7 election. On that day, said Pearson Cross,
assistant professor of political science at the University of Louisiana at Lafayette,
voters likely will be looking to Melancon's record in the past two years, not Romero's possible
record, when deciding whom to send to Washington. "This election is
a referendum on Melancon and the job that he's done
in Congress, and it's less a referendum on who will do a better job, Melancon
or Romero. It boils down to: 'Is Melancon, in your opinion,
representing the district well and paying attention to your issues?' " |